The Norwegian Star receives generally positive reviews for its service, itineraries, and entertainment, but there are notable criticisms regarding food quality, ship maintenance, and communication about itinerary changes. Many guests praise the friendliness and professionalism of the staff, the variety of destinations, and the overall value. However, recurring complaints include slow or inconsistent dining service, mediocre or repetitive food, issues with excursions and port changes, and some aging aspects of the ship. The atmosphere is often described as relaxed and enjoyable, though some found the ship crowded or the entertainment lacking. Internet connectivity and specialty services receive mixed feedback. Overall, the Norwegian Star offers a solid cruise experience, especially for those prioritizing destinations and friendly service, but may fall short for guests seeking top-tier dining and amenities.