The Norwegian Star receives mixed reviews, with many guests praising the friendly and helpful staff, excellent entertainment, and diverse itineraries. However, there are recurring criticisms regarding food quality and variety, slow or inconsistent service in dining rooms, and issues with ship maintenance and amenities. Excursions and port changes are also a common source of dissatisfaction, with some guests feeling the value did not match the price. The ship's atmosphere is generally positive, but crowding and embarkation processes can be problematic. Overall, the Norwegian Star offers a good cruise experience, especially for those prioritizing destinations and entertainment, but it may fall short for guests with high expectations for dining and luxury.