Windstar's Wind Surf receives overwhelmingly positive reviews for its attentive service, excellent food, unique itineraries, and intimate, uncrowded atmosphere. Guests consistently praise the crew's friendliness and professionalism, the ship's cleanliness, and the overall value of the experience. Some areas for improvement include internet connectivity, occasional maintenance issues, and the cost of extras like excursions and Wi-Fi. The ship's smaller size and relaxed vibe are highlighted as major advantages, though a few guests mention the ship could use some updating. Overall, Wind Surf is highly recommended for those seeking a personalized, upscale cruise experience.